OUP user menu

Rhizobia with different symbiotic efficiencies nodulate Acaciella angustissima in Mexico, including Sinorhizobium chiapanecum sp. nov. which has common symbiotic genes with Sinorhizobium mexicanum

Reiner Rincón-Rosales, Lourdes Lloret, Edith Ponce, Esperanza Martínez-Romero
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1574-6941.2008.00590.x 103-117 First published online: 1 January 2009


Bacteria from nodules of the legume Acaciella angustissima native to the south of Mexico were characterized genetically and their nodulation and competitiveness were evaluated. Phylogenetic studies derived from rpoB gene sequences indicated that A. angustissima is nodulated by Sinorhizobium mexicanum, Rhizobium tropici, Mesorhizobium plurifarium and Agrobacterium tumefaciens and by bacteria related to Sinorhizobium americanum, Sinorhizobium terangae, Rhizobium etli and Rhizobium gallicum. A new lineage related to S. terangae is recognized based on the sequences of gyrA, nolR, recA, rpoB and rrs genes, DNA–DNA hybridization and phenotypic characteristics. The name for this new species is Sinorhizobium chiapanecum and its type strain is ITTG S70T. The symbiotic genes nodA and nifH were similar to those from S. mexicanum strains, which are Acaciella symbionts as well, with nodA gene sequences grouped within a cluster of nod genes from strains that nodulate plants from the Mimosoideae subfamily of the Leguminosae. Sinorhizobium isolates were the most frequently obtained from A. angustissima nodules and were among the best strains to promote plant growth in A. angustissima and to compete in interstrain nodule competition assays. Lateral transfer of symbiotic genes is not evident among the genera that nodulate A. angustissima (Rhizobium, Sinorhizobium and Mesorhizobium) but may occur among the sympatric and closely related sinorhizobia that nodulate Acaciella.

  • Acaciella angustissima
  • N2 fixation
  • nodulation
  • rhizobial diversity
  • legume symbiosis


Bacteria in the roots or the stems of legumes fix nitrogen and provide the plant with this nutrient. Symbiotic bacteria have been studied from only a small proportion of the extant legume species, and diverse genera such as Rhizobium, Sinorhizobium, Mesorhizobium, Bradyrhizobium, Devosia, Methylobacterium, Burkholderia and Cupriavidus have been reported to contain nodulating species (Young & Haukka, 1996; Sprent, 2001; Syet al., 2001; Rivaset al., 2002; Chenet al., 2003; Vandamme & Coenye, 2004; Elliottet al., 2007a, b). Mexico is a very diverse country and occupies the fourth place in plant diversity terms (Rzedowsky, 1978) with many endemic legumes. The genus Acaciella is found mainly in Mexico and has well-supported botanical differences to be recognized as a new species different from the Acacia genus where it was formerly classified (Rico-Arce & Bachean, 2006).

Nitrogen-fixing trees and shrubs are valuable to maintain forest fertility and N2 fixation allows their growth in infertile soils while enriching soil nitrogen. In Chiapas, Acaciella angustissima shrubs that can grow in poor soils are being used in agroforestry systems, due to their rapid growth rate, high capacity for nitrogen fixation and the quality of the tannins that accumulate in their bark (Rincón-Rosales & Gutiérrez-Miceli, 2008). Interestingly, these shrubs are the preferred hosts of Llaveia mexicanorum (Williams & MacVean, 1995), a native homeoptera scale insect, which is used by indigenous people of Chiapas and Mesoamerica to produce a fat for traditional lacquer wood handcrafts (Grillasca, 2007). We established nurseries to propagate A. angustissima plants and became aware that inoculants were required to attain good plant development. This prompted us to analyze and select strains for inoculation.

One of the sinorhizobial groups we encountered corresponded to a new species and we proposed the name Sinorhizobium mexicanum for this lineage (Lloretet al., 2007). However, modifications in the Sinorhizobium genus taxonomy have occurred (Young, 2003). The bacteria belonging to Sinorhizobium have been transferred to the genus Ensifer (Young, 2003) because according to judicial rules, Ensifer has priority over Sinorhizobium. This new Sinorhizobium species had to be named as Ensifer mexicanus (Lloretet al., 2007) instead of S. mexicanum. In this work, we chose to use the former name Sinorhizobium as used in many recently published papers.

Sinorhizobium mexicanum was not the only symbiont found in A. angustissima nodules. The objective of this study was to characterize the other symbionts of A. angustissima in Mexico (including a novel sinorhizobial species), their interstrain nodulation competitiveness and their plant growth promotion in A. angustissima.

Materials and methods

Sample sites

Isolates used in this study were obtained from root nodules of A. angustissima collected from the Sumidero Canyon National Park in Chiapas, Mexico, and from nodulated trap plants grown in pots containing soils collected from an ecological reserve area in Sierra de Huautla in Morelos, Mexico (Supporting Information, Fig. S1). The Chiapas and Morelos collecting sites were c. 1000 km apart and both are characterized by deciduous forest vegetation (Lloretet al., 2007).

Bacterial strains

The A. angustissima strains analyzed in this study are listed inTable 1. Bacteria were obtained as described by Vincent (1970) using peptone yeast agar (PY) as growth medium (Toledoet al., 2003). Plates were incubated aerobically at 28 °C for 3 days and the isolates were purified by streaking single colonies on fresh PY plates. Single colony formation and morphology were observed in yeast extract mannitol (YEM) and PY media at 28 °C as reported by Toledoet al. (2003). The acid/alkaline reaction was verified by spreading the inoculum on YEM plates (pH 7.0) containing 25 μg mL−1 bromothymol blue (Vincent, 1970).

View this table:

Bacteria isolated from nodules of Acaciella angustissima

Species and strainsGeographical origin
Agrobacterium tumefaciens
ITTG S2Chiapas, Mexico
ITTG S6Chiapas, Mexico
ITTG S9Chiapas, Mexico
ITTG S10Chiapas, Mexico
CFN ESH11Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH16Morelos, Mexico
Mesorhizobium plurifarium
CFN ESH5Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH18Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH19Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH22Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH26Morelos, Mexico
Rhizobium sp. (R. gallicum related)
ITTG S11Chiapas, Mexico
Rhizobium sp. (R. leguminosarum/R. etli related)
CFN ESH6Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH7Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH34Morelos, Mexico
Rhizobium tropici
CFN ESH9Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH10Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH23Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH25Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH27Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH29Morelos, Mexico
ITTG S7Chiapas, Mexico
Sinorhizobium sp. (S. americanum related)
ITTG S8Chiapas, Mexico
Sinorhizobium chiapanecum sp. nov.
ITTG R11Chiapas, Mexico
ITTG S1Chiapas, Mexico
ITTG S68Chiapas, Mexico
ITTG S70TChiapas, Mexico
ITTG S71Chiapas, Mexico
Sinorhizobium mexicanum
CFN ESH1Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH2Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH3Morelos, Mexico
CFN ESH4Morelos, Mexico
ITTG R4Chiapas, Mexico
ITTG R7TChiapas, Mexico
ITTG S3Chiapas, Mexico
ITTG S4Chiapas, Mexico
ITTG S5Chiapas, Mexico
ITTG S64Chiapas, Mexico
  • * Identity according to the sequence analysis of the chromosomal gene rpoB.

Nodulation tests

Acaciella angustissima seeds were scarified with H2SO4 for 15 min and surface sterilized with 1% (v/v) sodium hypochlorite for 10 min. Treated seeds were germinated on 0.8% agar–water plates and then placed in glass tubes filled with vermiculite moistened with Fahraeus medium (Fahraeus, 1957). Inoculation tests were also performed with Acacia farnesiana, Leucaena leucocephala and Phaseolus vulgaris cv. Negro Jamapa as described (Lloretet al., 2007). Bacteria for inoculation were grown in individual PY plates and suspended in 1 mL sterile distilled water, serially diluted, and absorbance was determined at A600 nm. Final cell numbers were determined by plating on PY medium to count CFUs. Approximately 106 bacteria mL−1 were added to each plant rootlet and the plants were grown in a plant growth chamber at 28 °C (Räsänenet al., 2001). A negative control with uninoculated seedlings was included. After 30 days, surface-disinfected nodules were harvested and crushed in PY plates and single colonies were picked up and reinoculated for their authentication. Bacteria were conserved in 65% glycerol–PY broth and stored at −80 °C. Working cultures were maintained on YEM slants at 4 °C (Vincent, 1970).

DNA isolation, genomic fingerprinting and DNA–DNA hybridization

Isolates were grown overnight in 2 mL PY. Total DNA was isolated and purified using the Genomic Prep kit (Amersham). Enterobacterial repetitive intergenic consensus (ERIC) genomic fingerprinting was obtained by PCR using primers ERIC1R and ERIC2 as described by Versalovicet al. (1994). The fingerprints were visually analyzed after resolution of PCR products using electrophoresis in 1.5% agarose gels loaded with half the volume of the 25 μL PCR reaction. ERIC fingerprinting was used only to confirm that the isolates analyzed were not clones or siblings (Ormeño-Orrilloet al., 2006; Lloretet al., 2007). Strains showing different patterns were considered for sequencing and phylogenetic analysis. The DNA relatedness was determined using DNA–DNA hybridization experiments using 32P-labelled DNA of the newly proposed species (described below) Sinorhizobium chiapanecum ITTG S70T as a probe. A filter hybridization method described previously was used (Martínez-Romeroet al., 1991). The amounts of DNA were standardized using integrating gel fluorescence with the Eagle Eye II system (Stratagene). anova and t-tests were performed to compare the percentage of DNA–DNA hybridization values among species and within species using angular transformation of percentage data (Knudsen & Curtis, 1947; Martínez-Romero & Rosenblueth, 1990).

PCR amplification and gene sequencing

An internal fragment of the chromosomal genes gyrA, nolR, recA, rpoB and 16S rRNA gene (rrs), and the symbiotic genes nifH and nodA were amplified using standard PCRs. Primers and annealing temperatures used for gyrA, nolR, recA, rrs, rpoB and nifH genes were performed as described in Lloretet al. (2007) and by Haukkaet al. (1998) for nodA. Before sequencing, the amplification mixture was purified using the PCR product purification system of Roche. The sequences generated were deposited in the GenBank public database and their accession numbers were included in the phylogenetic trees.

Phylogenetic analysis

The protein-coding sequences were aligned using the program clustal w (Thompsonet al., 1994) and then aligned based on codons using dambe v4.2.13 (Xia & Xie, 2001). The alignments were edited with bioedit v5 (Hall, 1999). The best-fit evolutive models for each set of sequences were selected by the AKAIKE information criterion implemented in the modeltest v3.06 (Posada & Buckley, 2004). rpoB gene sequences were analyzed using the TrN+I+Γ model of evolution based on an alignment of 642 nucleotides from positions 3262 to 3903; nodA using the GTR+I+Γ model with 522 nucleotides from positions 67 to 588; nifH with the TrN+I+Γ model of evolution based on 474 nucleotides from positions 313 to 787; and for the gyrA, recA and nolR genes the model of evolution and alignment positions were as reported by Lloretet al. (2007). These positions were based on the rpoB, nolR, nodA and nifH genes of Sinorhizobium meliloti 1021 and recA and gyrA of Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58. The phylogenetic trees were inferred with the maximum-likelihood (ML) method using the program phyml v2.4.4 (Guindon & Gascuel, 2003) considering the α-parameter for the Gamma distribution and the proportion of invariable sites estimated by the program. For the inference of the rrs phylogenetic tree, Sinorhizobium type strains were analyzed by the neighbor-joining method (NJ) (Saitou & Nei, 1987) implemented in mega v3.1 (Kumaret al., 2004) using the TrN+G model with the α-parameter for the Gamma distribution estimated with modeltest. The rrs phylogenetic tree was constructed using an alignment of 1417 nucleotides from positions 28 to 1444 with respect to the rrs gene of S. meliloti 1021. The topology robustness was estimated by a nonparametric bootstrap test using 100 pseudoreplicates for ML and 1000 for NJ.

Competition assays

The nodulation capacity was evaluated in competition assays of S. mexicanum ITTG R7T or S. chiapanecum ITTG S70T against one randomly selected strain from each of the bacterial groups identified previously by rpoB gene sequence analysis. Twenty-one treatments resulted from the 12 combination mixtures plus each of the eight single strains as positive nodulation controls, and the negative control (uninoculated plants). Four replicates of inoculated plants were used per treatment. The plant growth conditions were as mentioned above for nodulation tests. The competitiveness was evaluated by the number of nodules obtained from each member of the mixture with respect to the total number of nodules. The identity of the reisolated strains was determined by plasmid patterns using the Eckhardt procedure (Eckhardt, 1978). The variation in nodule number was analyzed statistically by anova using sas software (SAS Institute Inc., 1989), followed by comparison of means by Tukey's test (P<0.05).

Plant inoculation assays

The strains with the best nodulation capacity and high competitiveness were used as inoculants. Germinated seedlings of A. angustissima were planted in vermiculite tubes with Fahraeus medium (Fahraeus, 1957) and inoculated as described above. Plants without inoculum, with or without 30 mg KNO3-N per plant, served as control (Hungriaet al., 2001). Six replicate tubes were used per treatment and these were arranged in a completely randomized design. The plants were grown in a climate chamber at 28 °C for 90 days. At harvest, the shoot height, shoot dry weight, root dry weight and nodule number were determined, and total shoot nitrogen was assayed using the Kjeldahl method (Bremner & Mulvaney, 1982). The effect of the inoculation was analyzed statistically by anova, followed by comparison of means using Tukey's test (P<0.05).


Strain identity, diversity and phylogeny

A total of 94 strains were obtained from A. angustissima root nodules in Chiapas and Morelos that were confirmed to form nodules in the original host. Thirty-eight strains that represented the different ERIC-PCR electrophoretic patterns were used for PCR amplification and sequencing. The taxonomic position of the selected strains from A. angustissima was determined according to the phylogenetic analysis performed with partial sequences of the chromosomal gene rpoB, which encodes the β-subunit of RNA polymerase (Fig. 1).


Phylogenetic tree estimated using the ML method with partial sequences of the chromosomal protein encoding gene rpoB using the phyml program. The alignment length was 642 nucleotides from positions 3262 to 3903 of the rpoB gene of Sinorhizobium meliloti 1021. Only bootstrap values ≥50% are shown. Type strains are indicated by superscript T. The Acaciella angustissima strains are shown in bold. Only haplotypes were included in each terminal branch. The accession numbers for the sequences are indicated within parentheses. Those generated in this work are shown in bold.

The largest percentage of isolates found at both sites corresponded to S. mexicanum (26.3%) while the lowest corresponded to bacteria related to S. americanum and Rhizobium gallicum, both with 2.6%. A new lineage related to S. mexicanum and Sinorhizobium terangae was isolated only in Chiapas while only the strains related to Rhizobium etli and Mesorhizobium plurifarium were found in Morelos. The largest percentage of the isolates in Chiapas corresponded to S. mexicanum (33.3%) and in Morelos Rhizobium tropici (30.0%).

The Sinorhizobium sp. strain ITTG S70Trrs gene was found to be different from all sequences available in the GenBank database and had 99% identity to its closest relative S. mexicanum. The phylogenetic tree with the sequences of rrs genes (Fig. 2) and the phylogenetic trees with rpoB (Fig. 1), gyrA, nolR and recA genes (Fig. 3) were constructed including all of the type strains of Sinorhizobium species. The recA gene has been used previously in rhizobial phylogenetic studies (Gauntet al., 2001; Vinuesaet al., 2005); gyrA, recA, nolR and rpoB were used previously to describe a new Sinorhizobium species (Lloretet al., 2007). gyrA encodes the alpha-subunit of DNA gyrase, nolR encodes a transcriptional regulator (Chenet al., 2000, 2005) and recA encodes the recombination protein RecA. In all phylogenetic trees, the position of strain ITTG S70T as a different lineage within the Sinorhizobium genus was well supported. Strains ITTG R11, ITTG S68 and ITTG S71 had sequences identical to those from ITTG S70T that was chosen to represent this new lineage.


Phylogenetic tree estimated by the NJ method with the sequences of rrs genes using the Tamura Nei model considering gamma (α-parameter=0.9271). The alignment length was 1416 nucleotides, from positions 28 to 1444 of the rrs gene of Sinorhizobium meliloti 1021. Only bootstrap values ≥50% are shown. Type strains are indicated by superscript T. Sinorhizobium chiapanecum is shown in bold.


ML phylogenetic trees of partial sequences of the chromosomal protein encoding genes gyrA, recA and nolR. Type strains are indicated by superscript T. Only bootstrap values ≥50% are shown. The accession numbers for the sequences are indicated within parentheses. Those generated in this work for Sinorhizobium chiapanecum are shown in bold. The branches corresponding to the outgroup sequences Rhizobium leguminosarum USDA 2370T and Rhizobium etli CFN42T for the nolR tree are not shown because they were too divergent from the Sinorhizobium sequences.

Total DNA from the strain ITTG S70T showed low hybridization with the strains belonging to S. mexicanum (<42%) and S. terangae (<56%), while hybridization to three strains from its own group, ITTG S68, ITTG S71 and ITTG R11 (>74%), was higher than the limit proposed for new species (70%, Stackebrandtet al., 2002) (Table S2). DNA–DNA hybridization differences between S. chiapanecum strains and the closest species, S. mexicanum and S. terangae, were statistically significant with P<0.05 and P<0.10, respectively. It remains to be established whether similar plasmids in S. terangae and S. chiapanecum account for part of the DNA hybridization obtained. Description of species should be based on chromosomal and not plasmidic characteristics (Martínez-Romero & Jarvis, 1993). Also, phenotypic differences distinguishing S. chiapanecum, S. terangae and S. mexicanum are presented as Table S1.

The DNA–DNA hybridization, the phylogenetic position and phenotypic characteristics support that this Sinorhizobium lineage corresponds to a new species within the genus Sinorhizobium, and the proposed name is S. chiapanecum because it was isolated in Chiapas.

The nifH and nodA phylogenetic trees are shown inFigs 4 and 5, respectively. Symbiotic genes from the different rhizobia isolated from A. angustissima had affiliations with the corresponding genes from species in the genera Rhizobium, Sinorhizobium and Mesorhizobium. The phylogenies of these two symbiotic genes were incongruent with the phylogeny obtained with the chromosomal gene rpoB. The nodA sequences from Rhizobium sp. strains CFN ESH6 and CFN ESH34 (related to R. etli) isolated from A. angustissima were similar to the nodA gene of Rhizobium giardinii H152T isolated from common bean in France, but with the nifH gene analysis these strains were found to be related to the nifH gene of R. etli bv. mimosae Mim2 isolated from Mimosa affinis in Mexico. The nodA and nifH genes of R. tropici strains CFN ESH23, CFN ESH25, CFN ESH10, CFN ESH29 and CFN ESH9 were related but not identical to nodA and nifH gene sequences from R. tropici CFN299 isolated from P. vulgaris in Mexico. The symbiotic gene sequences of S. chiapanecum and S. mexicanum isolated from A. angustissima clustered together and were related to a different and well-supported group that included mainly sequences from Sinorhizobium isolated from American legumes, among them, the strains Sinorhizobium sp. BR827 and BR816 from L. leucocephala in Brazil and S. americanum CFN EI156 isolated from Acacia acatlensis in Mexico. The nodA and nifH gene sequences from S. terangae, the closest relative of S. mexicanum according to rpoB gene sequences, grouped in a far distant cluster. Mesorhizobium plurifarium isolated from A. angustissima has nodA and nifH gene sequences similar to several Mesorhizobium species isolated from American and African hosts, mainly with the strains Mesorhizobium sp. DWO366 isolated from Acacia polyacantha in Kenya and Mesorhizobium sp. INPA78b isolated from L. leucocephala in Brazil.


Phylogenetic tree estimated using the ML method with partial sequences of the symbiotic protein encoding nifH gene using the phyml program. The alignment length was 474 nucleotides from positions 313 to 786 of the nifH gene with respect to the nifH gene encoded on the pSymA of Sinorhizobium meliloti 1021. Only bootstrap values ≥50% are shown. Type strains are indicated by superscript T. The Acaciella angustissima strains are shown in bold. The accession numbers for the sequences are indicated within parentheses. Those generated in this work are shown in bold. Host and geographical origin are in parentheses.


Phylogenetic tree estimated using the ML method with partial sequences of the symbiotic protein encoding the nodA gene using the phyml program. The alignment length was 522 nucleotides from positions 67 to 588 of the nodA gene with respect to the nodA encoded on the pSymA of Sinorhizobium meliloti 1021. Only bootstrap values ≥50% are shown. Type strains are indicated by superscript T. The Acaciella angustissima strains are shown in bold. The accession numbers for the sequences are indicated within parentheses. Those generated in this work are shown in bold. Host and geographical origin are in parentheses.

Nodulation and nodule occupancy in competition assays

Nodule occupancy evaluated from interstrain competition assays is shown inTable 2. The strains ITTG R7T, ITTG S70T, CFN ERSH34, CFN ERSH5 and ITTG S7 showed the best nodulation capacity and high competitiveness. Sinorhizobium mexicanum strain ITTG R7T always had a greater occupancy of the nodules than the respective competing strain, ranging from 65% when combined with Sinorhizobium sp. ITTG S8 to 100% when combined with Rhizobium sp. ITTG S11. The S. chiapanecum strain ITTG S70T did not always have a greater occupancy of the nodules than the competing strain, although this strain and S. mexicanum ITTG R7 were highly effective in inoculation assays with A. angustissima (Table 3). Mesorhizobium plurifarium CFN ESH5 and Rhizobium sp. CFN ESH34 had a greater occupancy than ITTG S70T (67% and 77%), respectively. Significantly lower numbers of nodules were obtained with M. plurifarium CFN ESH5, R. tropici ITTG S7, Sinorhizobium sp. ITTG S8 (related to S. americanum), Rhizobium sp. ITTG S11 (related to R. gallicum) and A. tumefaciens ITTG S2, with the latter showing the lowest number of nodules and very low nitrogen fixation. All reisolated strains showed colony morphology and plasmid patterns identical to the original inoculated strains (data not shown).

View this table:

Nodule occupancy by strains of Sinorhizobium mexicanum ITTG R7T and Sinorhizobium chiapanecum ITTG S70T and the coinoculated bacteria in competition assays in Acaciella angustissima

TreatmentsNodule number (per plant) (±SD)Nodule occupancy (%) by
First strain of the combinationSecond strain of the combination
A. tumefaciens ITTG S20.5 (±1.0)gh
M. plurifarium CFN ESH58.0 (±1.6)bcde
Rhizobium sp. ITTG S112.0 (±0.8)fgh
Rhizobium sp. CFN ESH3410.5 (±2.5)abc
R. tropici ITTG S74.0 (±1.6)defgh
Sinorhizobium sp. ITTG S82.25 (±2.1)fgh
S. chiapanecum ITTG S70T10.0 (±1.6)abc
S. mexicanum ITTG R7T14.0 (±3.7)a
S. chiapanecum ITTG S70T+A. tumefaciens ITTG S24.5 (±1.3)defgh61 (18)39
S. chiapanecum ITTG S70T+M. plurifarium CFN ESH54.5 (±2.6)defgh33 (18)67
S. chiapanecum ITTG S70T+Rhizobium sp. ITTG S114.25 (±1.7)defgh82 (17)18
S. chiapanecum ITTG S70T+Rhizobium sp. CFN ESH343.25 (±1.9)efgh23 (13)77
S. chiapanecum ITTG S70T+R. tropici ITTG S72.5 (±1.3)fgh80 (10)20
S. chiapanecum ITTG S70T+Sinorhizobium sp. ITTG S83.75 (±2.1)defgh67 (15)33
S. mexicanum ITTG R7T+A. tumefaciens ITTG S26.0 (±1.4)cdef75 (24)25
S. mexicanum ITTG R7T+M. plurifarium CFN ESH58.75 (±5.1)abcd89 (35)11
S. mexicanum ITTG R7T+Rhizobium sp. ITTG S115.5 (±1.9)cdefg100 (22)0
S. mexicanum ITTG R7T+Rhizobium sp. CFN ESH3412.0 (±1.4)ab71 (48)29
S. mexicanum ITTG R7 T+R. tropici ITTG S73.75 (±1.3)defgh67 (15)33
S. mexicanum ITTG R7T+Sinorhizobium sp. ITTG S86.5 (±3.4)cdef65 (26)35
  • * Mean values of four replicates. The means followed by the same letter are not significantly different (P<0.05).

  • In parentheses, total number of nodules analyzed.

View this table:

Effect of inoculation by the strains with high competitivity and nodulation capacity on the growth, nodulation and nitrogen fixation of Acaciella angustissima

StrainsShoot height (cm)Shoot dry weight (mg)Root dry weight (mg)Nodule numberTotal shoot N (mg per plant)
Uninoculated15.0 c76.1 b46.3 b0 b30.4 c
M. plurifarium CFN ESH516.5 bc95.0 b40.3 a2.1 b39.9 c
Rhizobium sp. CFN ESH3420.1 b101.0 b44.9 a2.3 b51.5 c
R. tropici ITTG S717.0 bc96.4 b42.9 a2.3 b44.3 c
S. chiapanecum ITTG S70T24.8 a112.9 a44.0 a5.3 a101.6 b
S. mexicanum ITTG R7T25.1 a134.7 a52.6 a5.8 a158.9 a
KNO3-N (30 mg per plant)15.3 c56.1 c25.3 b0 b22.4 c
  • * Mean values of six replicates. The means followed by the same letter are not significantly different (P<0.05).

Plant growth, nodulation and nitrogen fixation of A. angustissima inoculated with selected strains

The inoculation using the selected rhizobia strains had a significant effect on the growth of A. angustissima (Table 3). Rhizobium sp. CFN ESH34, S. mexicanum ITTG R7T and S. chiapanecum ITTG S70T had a positive effect on shoot height, shoot dry weight and root dry weight compared with the uninoculated control plants and those with added KNO3. Plants inoculated with these strains were on average 8.3 cm taller and weighted 109 mg more than noninoculated plants 90 days postinoculation. The number of nodules obtained with S. mexicanum ITTG R7T and S. chiapanecum ITTG S70T was significantly different (P<0.05) compared with the rest of the treatments. None of the noninoculated plants formed nodules. The plants inoculated with ITTG R7T showed a significantly higher total shoot nitrogen compared with other treatments (P<0.05). ITTG R7T was found to be the most effective strain in terms of plant growth promotion as indicated by total plant nitrogen content.

Characteristics of S. chiapanecum sp. nov.

Sinorhizobium chiapanecum (chia.pa.ne'cum. N.L. neut. adj. chiapanecum of Chiapas, the name of a state in Mexico where the bacterium was isolated). Gram-negative, aerobic, motile and nonspore-forming rods. Strains are fast growing and acid producers in YEM medium. The generation time for ITTG S70T in YEM broth is 2.33 h at 28 °C. Colonies on PY or YEM are circular, pearly, slightly translucent and produce copious amounts of polysaccharides. Colonies are normally more than 2–4 mm in diameter within 2 days of incubation at 28 °C. The strains are resistant to nalidixic acid (120 μg mL−1) but not to carbenicillin (20 μg mL−1), ampicillin (10 μg mL−1) or chloramphenicol (10 μg mL−1). They grow in media containing 0.5%, 1.0% and 2.0% NaCl but not with 3.0% NaCl. Total DNA from strain ITTG S70T showed low hybridization values with the strains belonging to S. terangae ORS1009T (<48%) and with S. mexicanum ITTGR7T (<33%). This species can be differentiated from other described Sinorhizobium species on the basis of the phylogenetic analysis of the chromosomal genes rrs, gyrA, recA, rpoB and nolR. The type strain ITTG S70T was isolated from nodules of A. angustissima collected in the Sumidero Canyon National Park, Chiapas, Mexico. Sinorhizobium chiapanecum ITTG S70T nodulated and fixed nitrogen in A. angustissima, Acaciella cochliancantha, Acaciella farnesiana, Acaciella pennatula, Dolichos lablab, P. vulgaris, L. leucocephala and Lysiloma acapulcensis and tolerated salinity and acidity (data not shown). ITTG S70T has characteristics of the species.


Tropical forests in Mexico harbor many endemic plants and a high richness of species (Rzedowsky, 1978). Forests have abiotic and biotic characteristics that allow such diversity to exist. Plant speciation in Mexico seems to be driven by geographical isolation due to the complex topography of the country. The tropics have a large diversity of rhizobia (Wanget al., 1999; Mohamedet al., 2000; Räsänenet al., 2001; Toledoet al., 2003; Wolde-Meskelet al., 2004). Sinorhizobia seem to have radiated in Mexico in relation to the geographical isolation and diversity of climates, conditions and plants (Toledoet al., 2003; Lloretet al., 2007). The sinorhizobia-nodulating legumes in Africa and in the Americas are considered to have had a long period of diverging evolution (Haukkaet al., 1998; Toledoet al., 2003; Lloretet al., 2007). Our results showed that A. angustissima was preferentially nodulated by closely related members of the Alphaproteobacteria, especially sinorhizobia. Differences in symbiotic efficiency and competitiveness were found among the isolates, with S. mexicanum and S. chiapanecum strains being highly effective symbionts and good competitors. In contrast to acacias, no bradyrhizobia or Betaproteobacteria strains were found nodulating this legume. Acaciella angustissima was among the legume hosts of Latin American origin that formed nitrogen-fixing nodules with the African sinorhizobial strains Sinorhizobium arboris HAMBI 1552T, Sinorhizobium kostiense HAMBI 1489T and S. terangae bv. acaciae ORS 1058 (Räsänenet al., 2001). Tropical legumes seem to have a mild specificity when associating with nodulating bacteria (Moreiraet al., 1998), although under natural conditions predominant rhizobial species may be preferentially encountered in promiscuous plants (Bala & Giller, 2001; Balaet al., 2003; Martínez-Romero, 2003) as shown here.

Mesorhizobium plurifarium strains originally isolated from Acacia senegal (de Lajudieet al., 1998) encompass a set of diverging strains. In this study, M. plurifarium strains were found in A. angustissima only in Morelos. In Mexico, M. plurifarium were found nodulating Sesbania (Papilioniodeae) trees (Wanget al., 1999) and L. leucocephala plants grown in Morelos soils. Acaciella and Leucaena belong to the Mimosoideae subfamily of the Leguminosae. Plant traps with soils from Morelos were used to collect the bacteria and it has been shown that by doing so a larger diversity of bacteria may be obtained nodulating a single legume (Hungriaet al., 2001), and so we predicted that Mesorhizobium strains were the less adapted to nodulate A. angustissima. This turned out to be true.

We found seven isolates of Rhizobium similar to R. tropici type A, with nod genes more closely related (but not identical) to nodA of R. tropici than to other nodA genes. Rhizobium tropici strains are common in tropical soils and nodulate some trees from the Mimosoideae subfamily of the Leguminosae such as L. leucocephala (Martínez-Romeroet al., 1991) as well as A. angustissima (not shown).

Rhizobium etli is commonly isolated from P. vulgaris (Segoviaet al., 1993), but has also been isolated from other shrub legumes in Kenya (Odeeet al., 2002). Biovars that refer to host specificity have been described in R. etli. Nodulation of Mimosoidea plants such as M. affinis and Leucaena spp. is the characteristic of biovar mimosae (Wanget al., 1999). It is probable that the Rhizobium sp. strains (related to R. etli and R. leguminosarum) from A. angustissima correspond to biovar mimosae. Strain ITTG S11 was found to be related to R. gallicum (Amargeret al., 1997). Rhizobium gallicum bv. gallicum was isolated from common bean and can also nodulate L. leucocephala (Amargeret al., 1997; Silvaet al., 2005) and other species from the Mimosoideae subfamily of the Leguminosae (Zurdo-Piñeiroet al., 2004) but it was not known that it nodulated Acaciella.

In addition, species of Agrobacterium were also found in this study. Bala & Giller (2001) reported that the legumes Acacia auriculiformis, L. leucocephala, Gliricidia sepium, P. vulgaris and Sesbania sesban formed effective nodules with one or more isolates that resembled A. tumefaciens. Agrobacterium strains have been isolated previously from nodules of Acacia mellifera, A. polyacantha, Acacia nilotica and S. sesban (Khbayaet al., 1998; de Lajudieet al., 1999) and shrubs growing in the semi-arid and arid climates of north-western China (Tanet al., 1999). Odeeet al. (2002) indicated that agrobacteria were often found in association with root nodules as a co-occupant with rhizobia. The Agrobacterium strains described here were capable of forming nodules on A. angustissima, but the nitrogen fixation was very low. Agrobacterium sp. ITTG S2 (similar to A. tumefaciens) showed a low level of competitiveness when inoculated in competition assays. Recently, some Agrobacterium strains were found to be capable of forming tumors on plants as well as nodulating (Rivaset al., 2004). In additional experiments, we evaluated the pathogenicity of the strains ITTG S2, ITTG S6 and ITTG S10 (all similar to A. tumefaciens) on sunflower plants (Helianthus annus) and found that these strains are not tumorogenic (not shown).

We showed that the phylogenies of the symbiotic genes were incongruent with the chromosomal genes as has been reported previously (Haukkaet al., 1998; Wernegreen & Riley, 1999; Laguerreet al., 2001; Toledoet al., 2003; Lloretet al., 2007). Symbiotic genes on elements such as plasmids and symbiotic islands are prone to lateral gene transfer (Sullivan & Ronson, 1998; Ochman & Moran, 2001) and may be selected by hosts (Uedaet al., 1995; Haukkaet al., 1998; Wernegreen & Riley, 1999), as observed here, because the two species S. mexicanum and S. chiapanecum nodulating Acaciella have the same nodA genes. The three main groups described based on nod gene sequences (Haukkaet al., 1998) corresponding to African and Latin–American sinorhizobia and some Mesorhizobium spp. were observed in the trees presented here with several more sequences included (Fig. 5). A large group was distinguished that corresponds to nod genes of symbionts with the capacity to nodulate many plants from the Mimosoideae subfamily of the Leguminosae (Fig. 5); it is worth noticing that within this group, R. giardinii and R. gallicum nod gene sequences were included.

Sinorhizobium sp. ITTG S8, a strain related to S. americanum, clustered in the rpoB tree with some American strains isolated from L. leucephala in Mexico (Wanget al., 1999) and with strain BR816 (van Rhijnet al., 1994) from Brazil. This group constitutes a sister clade to S. americanum and could have been identified as belonging to the same species, but unpublished DNA–DNA hybridization results from our lab showed that BR816 was not a member of S. americanum. A new biovar has been proposed (mediterranense) (Mnasriet al., 2007) to account for sinorhizobia closely related to Sinorhizobium fredii and with specificity for L. leucocephala and P. vulgaris. This biovar includes strain BR816 and some other strains that, despite being closely related to S. fredii, do not form nodules on soybean. In spite of the close relatedness of the symbiotic genes of bv. mediterranense and S. americanum to those from S. mexicanum and S. chiapanecum, we consider that A. angustissima symbionts would not correspond to biovar mediterranense because the isolates that we found to be closely related to biovar mediterranense were not efficient to nodulate A. angustissima, comprised only 2.6% of the original isolates and were outcompeted by S. mexicanum or S. chiapanecum.

Within the enlarged set of sequence data presented here, we observed that the nodA gene sequence from Rhizobium huautlense (not reported previously) forms a clade with other Sinorhizobium species nodulating Sesbania (Fig. 5), indicating the strong specificity for Sesbania nodulation and evidencing lateral transfer of symbiotic genes between Rhizobium and Sinorhizobium. The genetic coherence among symbiotic and chromosomal genes has been considered to be characteristic of rhizobia nodulating wild legumes (Wernegreen & Riley, 1999), but S. chiapanecum and S. mexicanum as well as R. huautlense and sinorhizobia from biovar sesbaniae, all from noncultivated hosts, do not follow this observation and show evidence of horizontal transfer of symbiotic genes.

Authors' contribution

R.R.-R. and L.L. contributed equally to this work.


Reuse of this article is permitted in accordance with the Creative Commons Deed, Attribution 2.5, which does not permit commercial exploitation.

Supporting Information

Additional Supporting Information may be found in the online version of this article:

Figure S1. Map of Mexico showing the location of field collection sites in Chiapas and Morelos.

Table S1. Phenotypic characteristics of Sinorhizobium chiapanecum strain ITTG S70T and related reference strains.

Table S2. Levels of total DNA-DNA relatedness as percent of hybridization of Sinorhizobium chiapanecum strain ITTG S70T isolated of A. angustissima with the S. mexicanum and S. terangae strains.

Please note: Wiley-Blackwell is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting materials supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing material) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.


We thank Posgrado of Ciencias Biologicas-UNAM and CONAcyT for a fellowship to R.R.-R. We also thank Aryana Chávez and Paola Espinosa for field work at the Sumidero Canyon National Park in Chiapas, Ivonne Toledo, M.A. Rogel and J.C. Martínez-Romero for their excellent technical assistance or sampling field work at the Sierra de Huautla, Morelos. We thank W.X. Chen, P. de Lajudie, E.T. Wang and K. Lindström for providing bacterial strains. We also wish to thank Lourdes Rico for her valuable contribution in the reclassification of the Acaciella genus. We thank Michael Dunn for reading this manuscript. Financial support was from DGAPA IN201106-3.


  • Editor: Karl Ritz

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/) which permits non-commercial reproduction and distribution of the work, in any medium, provided the original work is not altered or transformed in any way, and that the work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com


View Abstract